"The flight isn't over till the airplane is back in the barn." That's what my flight instructor used to say. I think he was trying to tell me that I should be careful when taxiing to the hangar and putting the airplane away. Perhaps we need to expand that to include maneuvering for landing. Too many pilots complete a successful flight only to crash on or near their destination airport.
If we take out collisions with other airplanes in the pattern and collisions with obstacles in the airport environment, we are almost always looking at a stall/spin situation. But why? Realtors like the phrase, "location, location, location." Flight instructors like the phrase, "airspeed, airspeed, airspeed."
OK, the airplane doesn't stall because we fly it too slowly. It stalls because we exceed the critical angle of attack. But if an airplane is to remain aloft, decreasing airspeed requires increasing the angle of attack. As the angle of attack increases it gets progressively closer to the critical angle of attack and therefore the stall. Once the airplane is flying within a few degrees of the critical angle of attack, any increase in load factors, such as beginning a turn or encountering some turbulence, will put it over the edge.
Of course we have to decrease our airspeed as we approach the airport and enter the traffic pattern. We also have to make some turns, deal with ATC or traffic at non-towered airports, figure out which runway is the one we're supposed to be heading to, configure the airplane for landing, run a checklist or two, brief passengers, etc. In other words, at exactly the time we have to start flying closer to the stall, we have to divide our attention among things other than actual airplane handling.
Of course these accidents only happen to inexperienced pilots, right? Absolutely not. In fact, informal analysis of many accident reports seems to indicate the contrary.
So what are some practical ways to decrease the likelihood of being involved in this kind of accident? Studying past accidents help to identify possible causes and contributing factors that all pilots can avoid. Let's look at a few real cases.
We have an accident where the airplane was over its maximum landing weight. That alone would not cause the stall, but for each additional pound of weight at a given airspeed, the wing must fly at a slightly greater angle of attack. This gets the wing closer to the critical angle of attack and decreases the safety margin. So let's make sure we always are operating within the manufacturer's weight and balance limitations. And even though we are within the limits, let's be particularly aware of the added risks when operating near the limits. Abrupt maneuvering is never good, but can be very unforgiving when the airplane is heavily loaded.
Another stall accident in the pattern involved a pilot who had a high concentration of over-the-counter cold and cough medications in his blood. These same medications have a demonstrated negative effect on performance and produce drowsiness. This also won't cause a stall but will make it difficult to concentrate and would certainly cause a delayed reaction to the onset of a stall. Let's be sure that we are as sharp as possible for our flights. Drugs, legal and otherwise, along with alcohol, dull our senses and slow our reaction times. Taking medications and flying isn't a good idea. Whatever condition is causing us to need medication might also be a good reason not to fly till we feel better.
There is an accident where the pilot of a high performance, technically advanced airplane did not complete any factory authorized training but got a "check-out" from a local CFI who had no previous experience in the type of airplane. It is essential for every pilot to be comfortable with the characteristics of the airplane when flying near the stall. It's much better to learn about any unusual flying characteristics from someone who is accustomed to the airplane. Doing a checkout with a CFI who has no experience in the airplane just means there are two test pilots instead of one. I once decided to check myself out in a newly designed airplane. I learned that slips with full flaps made the flight path resemble that of a lawn dart. Upon further checking, I found out that I had "discovered" a well-known flight characteristic.
This applies not only to technically advanced airplanes. The light sport airplanes (LSA) can pose just as much risk to a pilot accustomed to flying a heavier single-engine airplane. So let's be sure we take whatever steps are necessary to become comfortable with any airplane we fly.
Finally there was the pilot who made an error in lining up with the assigned runway at a controlled airport and stalled when he abruptly turned after a controller calmly pointed out his error and assigned a new heading. Being more familiar with the stall characteristics, particularly accelerated stall characteristics might have prevented this accident. But studying the airport layout and having the airport diagram out as the airport was approached might have prevented the confusion that caused the pilot to execute the maneuver.
So my tips are nothing that we don't already know. Stay within weight and balance limits, don't fly when sick or taking most medications, know the flying characteristics and especially the stall characteristics of the airplane, and plan ahead for the arrival into the traffic pattern. Knowing what is safe is useless unless we practice what is safe.
|